Plymouth, IN Average Rent & Rental Yield
Compare average asking rent (median), gross rental yield, home value, and transaction activity before moving into listing-level underwriting or investor discovery.
Average rent in Plymouth, IN
The median asking rent in Plymouth, IN is $1,800 as of June 2026, based on active rental listings across the metro. We report the median — the midpoint of asking rents — because it tracks the typical listing more reliably than a simple average, which luxury and outlier listings can skew.
Against an average home value of $307,098, that rent level prices Plymouth, IN at a 8.46% gross rental yield — compared with 9.42% across Indiana.
Metro vs state rental signal
The metro read is a first-pass screen. Compare it with the state baseline, then pressure-test taxes, insurance, vacancy, rehab, and financing assumptions at the property level.
Plymouth, IN rent and rental yield comparison
The current Plymouth, IN baseline is $1,800 median asking rent and 8.46% gross rental yield. Compare rent, yield, and home values with selected Indiana metros, then open a public report or Rental Insights for property-level follow-up.
Indianapolis-Carmel-Greenwood, IN
Indianapolis-Carmel-Greenwood, IN median asking rent is $1,875, $75 (4.2%) higher than the $1,800 median asking rent in Plymouth, IN.
- Median rent
- $1,875
- Gross yield
- 8.82%
- Avg home value
- $284,833
Louisville/Jefferson County, KY-IN
Louisville/Jefferson County, KY-IN median asking rent is $1,722, $78 (4.3%) lower than the $1,800 median asking rent in Plymouth, IN.
- Median rent
- $1,722
- Gross yield
- 9.73%
- Avg home value
- $230,847
Chicago-Naperville-Elgin, IL-IN
Chicago-Naperville-Elgin, IL-IN median asking rent is $1,650, $150 (8.3%) lower than the $1,800 median asking rent in Plymouth, IN.
- Median rent
- $1,650
- Gross yield
- 11.71%
- Avg home value
- $213,124
Terre Haute, IN
Terre Haute, IN median asking rent is $1,125, $675 (37.5%) lower than the $1,800 median asking rent in Plymouth, IN.
- Median rent
- $1,125
- Gross yield
- 12.98%
- Avg home value
- $83,210
South Bend-Mishawaka, IN-MI
South Bend-Mishawaka, IN-MI median asking rent is $1,400, $400 (22.2%) lower than the $1,800 median asking rent in Plymouth, IN.
- Median rent
- $1,400
- Gross yield
- 12.79%
- Avg home value
- $129,370
Muncie, IN
Muncie, IN median asking rent is $1,250, $550 (30.6%) lower than the $1,800 median asking rent in Plymouth, IN.
- Median rent
- $1,250
- Gross yield
- 13.17%
- Avg home value
- $132,526
Marion, IN
Marion, IN median asking rent is $1,200, $600 (33.3%) lower than the $1,800 median asking rent in Plymouth, IN.
- Median rent
- $1,200
- Gross yield
- 14.75%
- Avg home value
- $85,236
Peru, IN
Peru, IN median asking rent is $1,050, $750 (41.7%) lower than the $1,800 median asking rent in Plymouth, IN.
- Median rent
- $1,050
- Gross yield
- 15.71%
- Avg home value
- $70,250
Plymouth, IN rent and yield FAQ
Quick answers based on the latest Plymouth, IN rental listing and transaction data.
What is the average rent in Plymouth, IN?
As of June 2026, the median asking rent in Plymouth, IN is $1,800. SFR Analytics reports the median of active rental listings rather than a simple average so outlier luxury listings do not distort the figure.
What is a good rental yield in Plymouth, IN?
Plymouth, IN currently prices at a 8.46% gross rental yield, versus 9.42% across Indiana. Treat gross yield as a first-pass screen — it excludes taxes, insurance, vacancy, rehab, and financing, so underwrite at the property level before acting on it.
Move from Plymouth, IN market context to property-level screening
Open Rental Insights with Plymouth, IN selected, then pair the yield signal with investor activity and rental data workflows.